BenefitsAll

Let's Hope The Republican Health Care Plan Stays In The Basement


Everyone wants to see the Paul Ryan/Tom Price Affordable Care Act (aka Obamacare) replacement bill, even most Republican lawmakers. But Ryan and Price would rather look like a putz than reveal who will be the primary losers under their new plan. They are also afraid that their fellow Republicans will join the media in ripping their plan apart. They have no desire to be once again the objects of a mocking press, Democrats and Obamacare supporters for their inability to present a Republican, majority-supported Obamacare alternative plan.

After embarrassing leaks describing their reform paralysis at the Republican retreat in Philadelphia earlier this year, and the leaked draft that revealed a proposal to base tax credits on age instead of income, Ryan and Price literally went underground (House basement) to reveal their latest proposal to a select group of lawmakers. There's plenty to mock about this childish approach to drafting legislation. But like all things related to Republican health care reform efforts, this latest hide and seek stunt is about politics and not providing affordable health care. Ryan can't keep putting out bad proposals that the rest of the GOP won't support. At least not publicly. He failed in his promise from years ago to lead the effort to draft an Obamacare replacement bill and is now just a mere figurehead of the process. Health care reform is now a Senate and White House effort with Ryan serving as secretary and spokesperson.

And with Senator Mitch McConnell and Secretary Tom Price leading the effort, we can expect more drastic cuts to federal subsidies and fewer people with insurance coverage than if Ryan had pushed through all of his lackluster reform ideas. McConnell has always wanted to push health care reform back to the states via high-risk pools and other disproved policies. But states have made it clear that they need federal government funds and they like the money Obamacare provided. Therefore, I expect the new Republican health care reform bill to grandfather Medicaid expansion for the states that adopted it. And based on past Ryan/Price proposals and the Trump Joint Congressional speech this week, we can easily assume that the crux of the law includes health savings accounts and tax credits that will mostly benefit the well-off, healthy and young.

Health savings accounts, skimpy plans, and tax credits are idea for the target customers of a company like Oscar Health Insurance. Oscar, is the health insurance company co-owned by Trump's son-in-law, Jared Kushner's baby brother and heavily financed by Trump surrogate, Peter Thiel. It was always going to be the case that Trump would protect the Kushner and Thiel Obamacare investment. So we can expect the federal exchanges to stay intact also.

And one last thing, the newly appointed head of the Medicaid and Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP) has experience making it harder for families to enroll in Medicaid and CHIP. Expect changes to Medicaid that require more copays for services, enrollees paying a portion of the health insurance premium and savings accounts.

blog comments powered by Disqus